Question
Hello everybody! We are startup company operating out of Germany. We are currently developing an innovative online platform to provide prototyping and additive manufacturing services. One feature of the platform will be an automatic pricing tool, which allows users to upload CAD data and get an instant quote for their desired product.
There are companies that offer similar tools on their websites. However, I have noticed that there are already patents related to that sort of online tool, such as US7305367. With a patent that describes a method/program claim, when does a similar online tool, developed independently from the patented technology, infringe the patent? Are all companies with similar online tools simply paying license fees or is the scope of the patent protection actually smaller than I think it is?
Thank you very much!
Answers: 1 public & 0 private
To infringe one or more claims of a patent, your method/system or apparatus must comprise every feature claimed in the one or more claims of the patent. Let's take a simple case - imagine you are the first one to invent a chair - so you claim at least one leg, because the chair could have a central pedestal-type leg, a seat connected to the leg, and a back connected to the seat - three features. A second person comes along and invents a padded-seat chair - he gets a patent because no one has thought of adding padding or cushioning to the chair seat in order to render it more comfortable, but since his chair also includes the three features of the first patent, he infringes that patent. Now, here's an interesting additional scenario - the first patent owner becomes aware of the second patented chair and the first patent holder wants to manufacture the padded chair because he realizes that most people will prefer the more comfortable chair, but he can't manufacture that chair without infringing the second patent. So, A, the first patent holder wants to make B's chair based upon the second patent but can't without infringing, and B can't make his own chair without infringing A's patent - so they cross-license each other saying that each can make the padded chair with no infringement.
Recent questions
I am looking for ...
3 6115 2