is it possible for me to publish work that is based on someone else's patented tech?

Question

For an academic study. I used technology that was patented by my mentor and implemented new technical features. Am I barred from publication because my study is based on a patent?

or

Answers: 2 public & 0 private

F56b616a4f
Lawyer

I fully agree with the basic principles of patent law outlined by Steven, with respect, I suppose, of an issued patent or published patent application (since you accessed freely there). Published patent titles are public documents its a fact, you are perfectly free to refer to their contents under your academic study.

And of course, if you propose improvements to the patented invention, I guess these will be displayed in your study only and that they will not be implemented "physically".

Under these reservations, the question of infringement of the concerned granted patent or published patent application does not arise in this context, whatever the law to which they belong. One does not infringe a (published) patent title only by offering to perfect (improve) the covered invention in a publication and just writing about it. This would be contrary to the very philosophy of patents that is to advance research through disclosure of the patented invention, in consideration of the private monopoly granted by the state.

However, I would especially like to draw your attention to another potential risk specifically incurred by technical and scientific publications. This risk is insidious in that it focuses on the patented invention in itself and falls under another area of ​​intellectual property. You have to know indeed that the content of a patent, notably its description (text) and drawings (figures), is a intellectual work by nature. And like any work, it can be considered protected by Copyright law despite its essentially technical and scientific aspect, as it shows a certain (supposed) originality (in the choice of words, their arrangement, the expression of ideas, artwork of operation of the invention ...). The content of a patent or a patent application is comparable to that of a classical book and any publications. Thus in France (my country) the courts have already had occasion in the past to recall that the text of a patent constituted an original work governed by the law of Copyright, as it could do it also about a manual, a technical notice or a software license agreement for example. And this position is not unique to France in that it is intended to be universally accepted.

Therefore, I recommend you as well to take some precautions in writing your study, in the event that you would have to reproduce "verbatim" whole extracts of the description of the invention (supporting the claims) and / or figures (explaining how its works) : act as if you were referring to the contents of a book, put all the reproduced passages in inverted commas and specify their origin well (patent references, identification of the inventor(s)), so as to avoid claims and possibly lawsuits from the author or co-authors of the patented invention for infringing - not the concerned patent right per se - but their supposed copyright on certain text elements and / or graphics (Figs) contained therein.

Your sincerely,
Simon

Recent questions