Are expired patents still prior art?

Question

If a patent lapses due to non-payment, could someone else just apply for the same technology? What would be a strategic reason to let a patent expire in the first place?

Answers: 4 public & 0 private

27bff8ce16
Patent Attorney

It might help to remember that this is the whole point of the patent system. Patent publications are publications for the public benefit. It is a one-way street:
- Once the patent application is published it becomes available as prior art. No-one can patent the same technology again. (Assuming the system is woking perfectly!)
- Once the patent has lapsed or exired (assuming a patent was even granted), then the technology becomes free for others to use. (Assuming what you are doing is not caught by other patents still in force!!)

The strategic reason for patents to lapse/expire is the public benefit. This is why maintenance fees are charged: patents WILL lapse unless the owner has a positive interest to keep them in force.

407362b526
Patent Attorney

As already stated by Steven and Edoardo, the short answer is yes for patents which expire or are abandoned after publication. It does not matter whether patents are still in force, as soon as they are published they are and remain prior art.

However, it is thus important to note that there is an important exception. Patents which expire or are abandoned before or without any publication will not be prior art. This might at first seem a scenario which is more an exception then a rule for most patent procedures, however it is especially relevant for procedures like US provisional patents which automatically expire after one year without publication.

8a416533c2
Patent Attorney

Hello,

yes, if the patent laspe it is still prior art, which mean no one can patent the same invention.

As for the reasons for letting a patent becomgina abandoned, there are several. It could an obsolete technology (i.e. VHS), it could be difficult to enforce, it may have been applied for only in order to create prior art, etc.

Steven weinrieb
Patent Attorney

The fact that a patent has lapsed has no bearing as to whether or not a patent is prior art - a patent may not be prior art depending upon its publication date relative to, for example, the filing date of a US application - if, for example, a US application is filed January 15, 2015, and a foreign patent has a publication date prior to that date, it is prior art. If the publication date is after the US filing date, even if it is before the publication date of the US application, it is not prior art. There are many other scenarios where some patent or patent application publication would or would not be considered prior art based upon filing and publication dates. Ordinarily, any patent, lapsed, still in force, whatever, can be prior art and someone cannot come along and apply for a patent with respect to that same technology. Actually, they could apply for a patent, but it would not be granted, or if granted, it would be invalidated if the claimed technology in the later patent is truly disclosed within the lapsed patent.
As for a strategic reason to let a patent lapse/expire, I cannot think of any - normally, patents are permitted to lapse or expire because the patent owner no longer wants to pay the annuities or maintenance fees - sometimes, the patent owner feels the fees are excessive/too expensive, or that it is simply not worth maintaining the patent in force because the patent is not being worked - the invention is not being practiced, licensed, or whatever.

At Robrecht Dumarey - please note that "patents" never expire or are abandoned before or without any publication - patent "applications" may be abandoned before publication, or provisional patent applications may never be made public, or accessible to the public, if they are not perfected into non-provisional or PCT applications. Patents, effectively by definition, are always published or made public, or are accessible to the public.

Recent questions

Do people really steal invention ideas?

I sometimes see questions on forums like Quora about how to stop people stealing your invention i...

4 5386 2
Is interpretation of known historical facts protectable under copyright law?

I am looking for useful sources on protecting copyright. I am in the process of writing a book ba...

3 6115 2
Fair Use and news feeds

What is the current wisdom on compiling news feeds on a third party website so far as copyright i...

1 3962 0
Looking for good patent firm

How to find a good patent firm to help me apply patent in USA

3 4320 2
What constitutes 'prior disclosure'?

This might be a silly question but I’m a bit confused by ‘prior disclosure’ as it applies to pate...

2 4823 1

Do you have a question about your invention or intellectual property?
Search the questions below or post your enquiry to one of our experts via Directory.
(User questions are no longer posted publicly on this page.)